The View From the Summit

Investing Daily’s annual Wealth Summit was held May 2-3 in Alexandria, Virginia. This was my second Wealth Summit, but the first after having a full year of The Energy Strategist under my belt. Whereas my 2012 presentation related my views on various energy sector patterns and trends, this year’s was more focused on specific investment ideas and portfolio holdings.

Only a small fraction of subscribers manage to make the trip, and I want to share a compact version of my presentation. The title of my talk was Future Currents: Where the Global Energy Sector Will Flow. While I touched upon several areas of the energy sector, the bulk of my talk was focused on the natural gas story.   

For the past year, I have believed that the natural gas sector is seriously undervalued. I have argued on an ongoing basis that natural gas prices must inevitably rise, and along with them the share prices of natural gas producers. As a result, my colleague Igor Greenwald and I spent the past year stocking the various Energy Strategist portfolios with natural gas producers.

I presented some 60 slides in my hour-long talk. I want to share about ten of them here. I opened by detailing my biography, my investment style (which I discussed in the previous Energy Strategist — see A Peek Inside My Portfolio), and some of my core philosophies about energy:

140514tesRRenergyphilosophies

I believe, given the importance of energy in the world, that most portfolios should have exposure to the sector. In fact, I believe that energy companies are frequently undervalued, which explains why the energy sector usually makes up the largest share of my portfolio.

Following some slides that provided a portfolio update covering 2013 through Q1 2014 — and we are outperforming the Energy Select Sector SPDR (NYSE: XLE) — I launched into the natural gas story. I started by orienting the audience to the largest oil and gas shale plays in the Lower 48:
140514tesRRshalebasins
For oil production, the household names are the Eagle Ford in Texas and the Bakken Formation in North Dakota. The Permian Basin in West Texas is also a rising shale star, although it has already produced billions of barrels of conventional oil since the 1920s.

The big names in shale gas are the Marcellus and Utica shales in the northeast, the Haynesville Shale that underlies parts of Arkansas, Louisiana, and Texas, the Barnett Shale located in north central Texas (south and west of Dallas), and the Woodford Shale of western Oklahoma and Texas.

I then moved on to the reasons that I believe natural gas producers in the US will be good long-term investments. The biggest driver over the next decade will be the start-up of LNG export terminals, which should start to ship out LNG late next year. Even if only a quarter of those applying for licenses ever export any LNG, the price movement should benefit all domestic natural gas producers.

140514tesRRlngexports
Regulatory drivers will also be important. Despite court challenges, US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) regulations on mercury and other toxic substances will force the closure of a number of coal-fired power plants. These will most likely be replaced by gas-fired power. The EPA recently upped its estimate of coal-fired power likely to be retired over the next five years by about 50 percent to 60 gigawatts.

140514tesRRepamercury
Likewise, the EPA has proposed limits on carbon dioxide emissions for power plants. And while these limits are also being challenged in court, I believe it is likely that they will be upheld, and this will continue to shift the balance of power production away from coal and toward natural gas.
140514tesRRepacarbon

My investment thesis over the past year has been that these long-term drivers would boost natural gas producers, but that it could take a year or two before the market broadly recognizes the opportunity. I noted that it is always possible for short-term factors like an unseasonably warm winter to briefly override the long-term drivers, but that patient investors should be rewarded.

Investors didn’t have to be patient for long.

I explained the nature of natural gas storage in the US, where demand is seasonal and inventories are depleted during the winter. The 2013-14 winter was unusually cold, and the resulting natural gas withdrawal from storage was the largest on record:

140514tesRRnatgasinventories

Historically, whenever inventories have been pulled below 1 trillion cubic feet (1,000 “billion cubic feet” in the graphic), there has been a significant and prolonged impact on natural gas prices. With natural gas inventories 53 percent below normal, natural gas drillers are going to have to produce at high rates for an extended period of time to catch up. Inventories are unlikely to reach normal levels by the start of high-demand season in mid-November, but natural gas producers will make a lot of money trying.

140514tesRRlongcoldwinter

Over the course of the past year, we have been steadily adding natural gas producers to the various Energy Strategist portfolios because of the long term outlook, but this cold winter had these companies outpacing expectations ahead of schedule. On May 13, 2013 — at last year’s Wealth Summit — I had one slide that simply read “Natural gas is cheap.” Indeed, natural gas prices rose and our portfolio holdings have benefited.

140514tesRRnatgashighlights

In fact, we now hold 10 of the top 20 natural gas producers in the US, most of which were added over the course of the past year. We are sitting on gains from all 10 in the model portfolios.

140514tesRRtop20producers

The takeaway message from me is that natural gas companies are going to do well. Six months ago this was an extremely compelling story; today with major upward moves by natural gas stocks across the board — which has helped drive the energy sector to the top of the major sector rankings thus far in 2014 — some of the companies have now reached or exceeded our Buy targets.

140514tesRRnatgastakeaways

Short term investors should select their entry points cautiously, because you don’t want to pile in just as a hot sector is about to embark on a correction. And it’s getting pretty hot. For investors with longer-term horizons, there are still numerous quality natural gas companies, so that if you get in just before a 10 percent pullback you should still be in good shape over the next five years.  

Conclusions

There you have a slice of my presentation, but it’s the meatiest slice from what I think is the most important part. The natural gas story has been a good one for us here at The Energy Strategist. While I personally felt like natural gas was a “no-brainer” a year ago, a lot of investors have now piled onto the bandwagon. Hopefully you were in early, and it has been a profitable year for you. But the story is far from over, and we will continue to scour for undervalued companies in this space, and we will add to positions should there be what we would consider a short-term pullback.    

(Follow Robert Rapier on Twitter, LinkedIn, or Facebook.)

Stock Talk

Ken S.

Ken Stephan

Robert,

If you are anticipating a pullback or correction in the NatGas sector, would you be willing to offer some guidance for investors with shorter term time horizons? For example, could you identify the TES portfolio holdings that might be hit the hardest in such a correction? Or other names that might ride through it relatively unscathed? How about hedging via OIH (or other sector related) put options?

Robert Rapier

Robert Rapier

Hi Ken,

I think those which have larger fraction of their production in natural gas are more vulnerable short-term. I could see Cabot pulling back a bit, but think the long-term is going to be very rewarding for this one. Rice Energy is one that has large natural gas exposure, and they have had a big run-up since their IPO. They could be vulnerable to a pullback as well. Other major gas producers like Devon and ConocoPhillips have substantial enough oil production that they are unlikely to see a hit unless oil prices also soften.

Add New Comments

You must be logged in to post to Stock Talk OR create an account