Trade Alert: Taking a Spin on Harley (HOG)

Earlier this year, Milwaukee-based motorcycle manufacturer Harley-Davidson (NYSE: HOG) unwittingly became the poster child for U.S. trade policy. The company was cited by European trade officials as an example of the type of American goods that would suffer if President Trump made good on his vow to place steep tariffs on steel and aluminum produced overseas.

The war of words placed Harley squarely at the center of a controversy that put downward pressure on its share price. After peaking above $55 in January, HOG briefly traded below $40 in early May. Since then, it has gradually risen to close at $45 this week as relations between the U.S. and Europe appear to be improving.

However, HOG still looks undervalued according to my IDEAL Stock Rating System which gives it a perfect score of 10 due to its dividend yield of 3.3%, strong cash flow, and forward PER (price to earnings ratio) of 12.7 – a third less than the multiple for the S&P 500 Index.

From a technical perspective, HOG has been achieving higher highs and higher lows for the past month while its RSI (relative strength index) recently crossed above 60. Its next resistance level is near $49, about 9% above the $45 strike price I am using for this trade.

According to Bloomberg, Harley’s sales in Europe have been mostly unaffected by the trade rhetoric. If so, then the primary reason for Harley’s share price decline may not have as much of an impact on this year’s sales as originally feared. We’ll get a better idea of how the year is shaping up when the company releases Q3 results on October 23.

I don’t expect that news to push HOG beyond $50, but I believe it will justify a share price above $45 which is all we need to earn an annualized options yield of nearly 18% on this trade.

Regardless of how many contracts you sell, it’s absolutely critical that you follow the instructions below, particularly when it comes to setting the limit order.

How to Make the Trade:

  • Trade: Sell to open the January 18, 2019, $45 put option on Harley-Davidson (NYSE: HOG).
  • Symbol: HOG190118P00045000
  • Limit Order Price: a credit of $2.50 or more.

Tell your broker: “I want to sell a put on Harley-Davidson stock. Specifically, I want to ‘sell to open’ one $45 Put that expires on January 18 for a credit of $2.50 per share or more.”

Note: Sell one put for every 100 shares of Harley-Davidson stock you would be pleased to buy at $45 per share. Investors should set aside $4,500 per contract sold to buy the stock in case the option expires in the money.

Further Instructions Regarding the Trade:

    • If the option price changes, you can adjust our recommended limit based on the midpoint of the bid/ask spread, which you should be able to see when entering the trade. Just make sure the potential credit is at least equal to the Limit Order Price specified above.
    • Place your limit order on a “good ’til canceled” (GTC) basis and be patient.

Stock Talk

George McMillion

George McMillion

Just filled HOG Jan. Put @ 2.55 Credit on TOS @ 06:45:21

Thanks Jim , have a good weekend.

Daniel Long

Daniel Long

HOG STO Jan 18 P 45 filled at Fidelity @ 2.50 credit.
Thanks, Jim.
DL

Jeffrey J

Jeffrey J

Filled @ $2.50 at TradeStation.

Cyan

Cyan

Filled at 2.50 credit.

Ken L

Ken L

HOG filled at 2.50 at Fidelity

Roger Dehring

Roger Dehring

Have always been a fan of HOG, Jim,

After all, they are a good Wisconsin company. Designed my trade a bit different than you. Sold 16-NOV 42.5/40 puts for +$0.47. A bit under my 20% minimum rule, but close.

Then bought a half position of a NOV/JAN 47.5/45 diagonal for a -$1.66 debit. Should be able to get all/most of my investment back with a November roll to either JAN 47.5 or JAN 50. Profit will come if HOG closes above 45 come January.

Stanley

Stanley

HOG filled this morning for 3.15

Curtis

Curtis

Hi Jim, should we expect an update to the portfolio soon showing the fill price? Thanks, Curt

ETKTRIDE

ETKTRIDE

HOG Jan $45P – was assigned

HowieA

HowieA

Jim – what do you suggest those of us who have been assigned HOG do? Hold? Sell? Write covered calls? Thanks for your input, Howie

Jim Pearce

Jim Pearce

Howie (and ETKTRIDE) – l would hold onto HOG for now, but not sell a covered call yet. There has been no recent news to explain the drop in HOG, and it appears some combination of year-end window dressing and program selling is at work at the moment. If I am correct about that, then HOG should rally in January at which time selling a covered call would be more lucrative.

HowieA

HowieA

Good advise. Thank you.

Julie

Julie

Assigned as well on the $45

Stanley

Stanley

HOG
Also assigned on the 45

Ken L

Ken L

Also assigned on the 45

SLHLLC

SLHLLC

assigned on 45 as well

W Burton

W Burton

Like others,stock assigned at $45. Was not expecting that. Covering the trade took a sizeable chunk from funds set aside for option trading. Now means I may have to pass on some up coming trades you recommend. What actions could I have taken to minimize this ?
Until I can recover this trade I may have to only do trades where the underlying stock is less than $20.. Are your other recommendations in similar situations? (BBY,WDC)

Jim Pearce

Jim Pearce

Yes, many of our open put positions are current “in-the-money”, which means they could be assigned against us at any time. If that happens to you, then I do not recommend selling them right away since I believe they are currently oversold and likely to recover in early 2019. There appears to be a lot of year-end “window dressing” institutional selling in the stock market already, which will probably continue through the end of the month. But come January, I think many of these stocks will be start getting bought again. If I am correct about that, then holding off on making any additional trades for a few weeks may be the best way to engineer a recovery from this month’s extreme volatility.

Dannhauser

Dannhauser

Also assigned @ $45. How can this happen in that does it not make the expiration date meaningless. Fidelity advises it is random but it appears it must have happened to lots of us randomly

Jim Pearce

Jim Pearce

Option assignments are assigned randomly to each broker, and then randomly by each broker to their respective account holders (https://www.optionseducation.org/referencelibrary/faq/options-assignment).

Yes, a lot of put option contracts are being assigned this month due to extreme volatility in the stock market. That high level of assignment implies that many of those option holders believe they have maxed out in value, which in turn suggests that the market may be nearing a bottom. If so, then we should see many of those stocks rally soon, so I recommend holding on to them until January before deciding what to do with then.

W Burton

W Burton

Thanks for your reply. I was assigned BBY which was a Dec 15 expiration. HOG was assigned and was a Jan 18 expiration date IVZ and WDC are Jan 18/19 expirations and look like they are probable assigned stock candidates. Give me some other alternatives here. This is eating up my options trading cash. .

Jeffrey Y

Jeffrey Y

Assigned HOG on 45 and now I am now -26% down. Let’s hope the miracle happened in early 2019…

Maria R

Maria R

also got assigned on HOG

Stanley

Stanley

HOG follow up
HOG: Is it time for a covered call? Or just a naked play?
I had 10 contracts initially and now own 1000 shared at todays value I am
down $4800.
I would love to unload shares and target a future profit with an option.
I was looking at the May 35
Any advise would be great.
Thanks

Jim Pearce

Jim Pearce

I think it’s too soon to write a covered call on HOG. The company is scheduled to report Q4 and year-end results on January 29, so I’m waiting until then to see if that news pushes the stock back above $40.

Add New Comments

You must be logged in to post to Stock Talk OR create an account